Conflicting accounts cloud incident at Costello home

By Mike McGann, Editor, The Times

U.S. Rep. Ryan Costello (R-6).

After a local Congressman took to social media over the weekend to allege that two individuals from his opponent’s campaign trespassed at his home, harassed his wife and took pictures — an account in complete variance with that of the individuals involved, it remains unclear exactly what, if anything, occurred on Jan. 13 in a normally quite West Goshen neighborhood.

U.S. Rep. Ryan Costello took to Facebook Saturday evening to say his wife, Christine, a former top staffer for former state Sen. Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, had been harassed by two individuals at their West Goshen home.

“Politics may be a rough business at times, but I believe families should always be off limits,” Costello posted. “Today, two individuals came on to our property to take pictures of our home and then began to intimidate my wife when she asked what they were doing. I want to thank the West Goshen police for their quick response, we were able to get some footage of the incident and hope these individuals will be apprehended. I hope Chrissy Houlahan will tell her associates to stop these tactics and cease any further harassment of my family.”

Costello did not reply on Facebook to a reporter’s inquiry as to why he was sure it had to have been someone from Houlahan’s campaign — noting that he has a Republican primary opponent, Paul Linkmeyer, who has criticized Costello for failing to support President Donald Trump.

Further investigation suggests that the two were from Planned Parenthood Action Fund — a detail confirmed by the organization this week.

Linkmeyer, when contacted, said he and his campaign were not involved and condemned any such attacks on candidate families.

“This type of militant behavior, especially at the home of an elected Representative; has no place in our Republic,” Linkmayer said. “This type of behavior, destroying and attacking opponents and their property, blocking traffic, harassing and interfering with people trying to work, has become a normal routine for Democrats and is absolutely reprehensible. I condemn this sort of behavior in the strongest possible terms.”

Houlahan, too, condemned any such attack and said her campaign had nothing to do with it in a Facebook message Saturday night.

“I am so sorry to hear what happened to Rep. Costello and his family today,” Houlahan wrote. “Of course families are out of bounds, and no one, regardless of their political affiliation, should ever be harassed in their own home. However, this incident had nothing to do with me or my campaign and baseless accusations do not help anything or anyone, do nothing to heal our divide and do not advance solutions.”

Costello took that as an apology the next day — something Houlahan campaign officials stressed later that it was not, as again, they noted that they did not have anything to do with the incident.

“I understand that my opponent said she was sorry in a post last night,” he wrote. “I do accept her apology on the condition that she publicly ask her allies, associated groups and staff to stop this type of behaviors before it gets out of hand. I look forward to an exciting campaign where voters focus on our records and ideas rather than these underhanded tactics.”

West Goshen Police were called to the scene. According to the official police report, two men, one white and one black were seen in a late model Ford compact car with New Jersey license plates parked in front of the house.

According to the report, Christine Costello called her husband, after reportedly observing the two point at the house and then allegedly take pictures with an iPad. After talking to her husband, she walked down the driveway and one of the two men, the white man, approached her, asking to speak and saying something about Planned Parenthood, holding some papers. She declined and told the man not to come on to her driveway, which he did not, the report says. The car left, but the white individual continued his door to door canvass — a detail that matches with neighbor accounts, who say they had a Planned Parenthood person knock on their door.

That also aligns with comments from comments from Ben Halle, the Press Secretary from Planned Parenthood Action Fund. PPAF said that no pictures were taken and dropping off one canvasser in an area, with a second driving off to an adjoining neighborhood is pretty common. Halle said that PPAF has not endorsed Houlahan and is not coordinating canvassing operations with any campaign. This past weekend’s canvass was a regional canvass in Congressional Districts 6, 7 & 8 to take issue with the recent tax bill approved by Congress.

Halle did not identify the canvassers.

Rep. Costello also contacted the Capital Police, which is authorized to investigate any incident involving a sitting member of Congress. Officer John Delegan of the Capitol Police contacted West Goshen Police and, according to the report, appear to be satisfied with the township police’s handling of the situation.

Police traced the car to Enterprise Car Rental at Philadelphia International Airport. Enterprise declined to share rental information without a court order as of Jan. 15.

Costello’s original post led to a number of angry exchanges — ranging from a well-known Chester County ultra conservative suggesting that all liberals suffered from mental illness, to what appeared to be a threat by a Republican Party Area Leader to visit another poster, possibly with menacing intent. That leader, Michael Arcuri, Sr., or Area 25 did later offer a public apology to the individual.

   Send article as PDF   

Share this post:

Related Posts


  1. Diane Welsh says:

    I’d say that Congressman Costello owes Chrissy Houlahan and the “liberals” an apology.

  2. David says:

    I agree with a comment I read on Facebook. Ryan is suffering from PTSD. Remember how freaked out he was after the baseball shooting that he wasn’t at because he missed his ride? He’s not been right since. He’s afraid of those who protest peacefully outside his office. He’s afraid to have people come to his town halls. He’s just plain afraid. So this is probably how it’s going to be for the next year. I don’t think canvassers are a threat but then again I didn’t miss the ride to the baseball game where other people got shot. He deleted my comment on his campaign Facebook page and it was very respectful. Then he blocked me and all you see on his Facebook page or his sympathetic followers. They never got another side of the story. Oh well I know I’m not voting for him.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.